Libby sucked in a small breath. I looked away. “I thought I could push the kiss from my heart—with Karen.”
“The girl from the Italian place?” Libby asked.
I nodded my head. “Yeah, but we were only together for a bit and then broke up.”
Libby’s eyes looked sad. “Was she—your first?”
Nodding my head I whispered, “Yeah. I went pretty far with Claire Montgomery once in high school, but not all the way. I kept thinking about—”
“Thinking about what?”
Looking into Libby’s eyes, I attempted a smile. “You. It’s always been about you, Lib. Even that night with Karen, you filled my mind and I tried so fucking hard not to think about you.”
Swallowing, Libby looked away. “Abigail?”
“My poor attempt to push you out of my heart. I swear to you I haven’t seen or talked to Abigail in I don’t know how long. She was lying to you when she said we were together again, Lib. I swear to God.”
Her eyes snapped back to mine as I searched them. I saw nothing but trust. Trust and love. “I believe you. I hate that she played a part in pushing me to Zach.” Shutting her eyes she shook her head. “Luke, we’ve both wasted so much time and have done such stupid things. I don’t want to waste any more time on the past. I want to focus on the future.”
Pulling my head back, I looked at Libby with a surprised expression on my face. “Lib, you don’t hate me? I mean I hurt you so many times.”
Libby frowned. “I want to be honest with you too, Luke. Two nights ago Zach sent me a text. I was confused and not sure where things were going with us, so I sent him a text back. I told him I’d call him yesterday, but I knew Zach wasn’t who I wanted. He was never who I wanted. It’s always been you.” She glanced down. “That day you showed up at my dorm.” Shaking her head, she wiped a tear away. She slowly looked back up and our eyes met. “I’d give anything to take that back, Luke. Anything.”
I lifted her hand to my lips. The sounds of the ocean rolling onto the shore made my heart take flight. Libby’s eyes danced with regret. I never wanted to see that in her eyes again. “I’m going to love you so much, Libby, that you will forget that day with Zach. I’m going to make your body feel so incredible that you’ll only know and remember my touch.”
Wiping a tear away, Libby smiled. “You already made me forget him the moment you told me you loved me.”
My heart dropped as I gazed into Libby’s eyes.
Grinning bigger, Libby said, “As much as I love your mom’s chicken salad, I’d much rather have you.”
I glanced around. The beach was fairly empty, but it was still the middle of the afternoon. Looking over Libby’s shoulder, I noticed the house. There was a deck and under the deck it appeared to be storage. The shutters were shut and locked, indicating that no one was occupying the house.
Standing up quickly, I reached for Libby’s hands and pulled her up. I picked her up and threw her over my shoulder as she let out a scream. “Where in the world are you taking me?” She asked as she pushed herself up with her hands on my back.
“I want you, Lib. Now.”
Giggling she said, “What? Now? Where, Luke? People are walking down the beach!”
I walked to the house and set Libby down. “Oh my God. We’re trespassing, Luke.”
I pulled her behind the wood trellis that separated us from the ocean and quickly pulled her shirt up and over her head. Her black bikini top was pushing up her perfect tits. “Fuck,” I hissed through my teeth as I pushed her top up and began sucking on a nipple.
“Oh God,” Libby gasped as her hands went to my hair and began pulling.
I reached down and pulled out a condom from my pocket. I pulled my lips from Libby’s nipple and handed her the condom. “Take it, Lib.”
Her hands were shaking as she reached out and took the condom. I wasn’t sure if she was excited or nervous. Dropping down, I slowly began to pull Libby’s shorts down. Her matching black bikini bottoms quickly followed her shorts. She lifted her legs out of her shorts and bikini bottoms and stood there as I moved my hands up and down her perfect legs. They were muscular from running and sexy as fuck. I pushed her legs apart and lifted a leg.
“Ahh …” Libby called out as I swept my tongue over her hardened nub. I pushed two fingers inside of her and moaned with how wet she was. I moved my fingers in and out a few times and then stood up as I placed the fingers in my mouth and sucked on them. Libby’s mouth parted open slightly as her eyes widened.
“You taste so good, Lib.”
She bit down on her lip and closed her eyes quickly before opening them again.
“Lib, I always want you to know how much I love and adore your body.” She nodded her head. “I never want to hurt you, so you have to promise me you’ll always tell me if I do. Do you promise me, Lib?”
Nodding again, she held up the condom and smiled. “I promise you, Luke.”
I quickly pushed my shorts down and kicked them off to the side, releasing my throbbing dick. I took the condom and rolled it over my shaft. I glanced up and saw Libby watching me as she ran her tongue along her bottom lip.
“What do you want, Libby?”
Snapping her eyes to mine, they danced with excitement. She chewed on her lip for a few seconds before her eyes changed. Excitement was replaced with lust. “I want you to fuck me, Luke. I want to feel what being with you in nothing but raw passion is like.”
Swallowing hard and trying to keep my dick from exploding with Libby talking to me like that, I lifted her up as she wrapped her legs around me. I slowly sank her onto my dick. Inch by painfully slow inch.
She pressed her lips to mine as she panted out. “More. I want more.”
When I was all the way in, we stood there for a few seconds. I wanted to be buried inside her always. Our bodies felt connected. Each time with Libby it was more emotional than the last.
“Luke, you feel like heaven,” Libby whispered against my lips.
“God, Lib. So do you, baby. I wish we could be like this forever.” I pushed her against the house and pulled out of her a bit before moving back into her.
She let out a gasp and I looked into her eyes. “Promise me, Lib.”
She frantically nodded her head. “I will! I will! More, Luke. I want it harder—faster. I want to feel that you were in my body with every step I take.”
I gave her exactly what she wanted. With each pull out, I slammed back into her. Libby’s moans of pleasure were hot as hell. Libby looked down and bit her lower lip. “Oh God … Oh God … that’s so hot.” I knew she could see my dick moving in and out of her body and I was so turned on I wanted to let go. “Libby, baby I need you to come.”